This novel's (SG-1 #23) strongest point, for me, was the Stargate Atlantis setting. It's pretty unusual for an SG-1 plotline to delve into Janus's mysteries, but I like it when it happens (episodes include It's Good to be King and Moebius). The alternate Atlantis timeline depicted in this novel is interesting and different and works pretty well; the characters are done well across the board.
Melissa Scott brings us some Ancient technology |
Recommendation:
This one is a fun read. If you like SG-1 and Atlantis, you will like this crossover. If you're not familiar with Stargate: Atlantis, you will miss out on a lot, but you will probably be able to understand what you need to.
Spoilers:
The Pegasus team getting into Wraith enzyme worked well. It is kind of a bummer to not meet alternate Weir, but it's supposed to be, I think. No one likes Colonel Sumner, right?
Overall:
5.5 out of 7 chevrons engaged
Characters:
6 out of 7 chevrons engaged
Meaningful, interesting plot:
5 out of 7 chevrons engaged
Shippyness:
TBD when I find the book and have a chance to refresh my memory for specifics.
This one is a fun read. If you like SG-1 and Atlantis, you will like this crossover. If you're not familiar with Stargate: Atlantis, you will miss out on a lot, but you will probably be able to understand what you need to.
Spoilers:
The Pegasus team getting into Wraith enzyme worked well. It is kind of a bummer to not meet alternate Weir, but it's supposed to be, I think. No one likes Colonel Sumner, right?
Overall:
5.5 out of 7 chevrons engaged
Characters:
6 out of 7 chevrons engaged
Meaningful, interesting plot:
5 out of 7 chevrons engaged
Shippyness:
TBD when I find the book and have a chance to refresh my memory for specifics.
No comments:
Post a Comment